Israel, Zionism and the Media

Day: 13 July 2010

Walajeh – this is wrong

AL TUR, WEST BANK - APRIL 25: Palestinian workers wait for their employer to collect them after crossing into Israel on April 25, 2010 at the Olives Crossing in Al Tur, West Bank, a few kilometers north east of Jerusalem. West Bank workers queue before dawn to cross the separation barrier into Israel to be permitted to work on the Israeli side of the fence which divides the suburb which once formed part of Jerusalem. (Photo by Uriel Sinai/Getty Images)

The Jerusalem Post had a story yesterday about how a Palestinian village is being surrounded by Israel’s West Bank security wall which is squeezing the village towards an almost certain death.

Surely this is wrong.

The barrier threatens to outright smother Walajeh: The community of about 2,000 on the southwest edge of Jerusalem is to be completely encircled by a fence cutting it off from most of its open land, according to a Defense Ministry map.

the loop runs tightly around Walajeh’s builtup area, penning it within less than a square mile and isolating it from almost all its farmlands. Of 36 Palestinian villages that are or will be caught in the seam zone, none are as closely encircled as Walajeh, said Ray Dolphin, a UN barrier expert in Jerusalem.

Sadly, the security barrier is necessary to protect Israelis, but surely more can be done for the Palestinians affected by it.

Ahmed Barghouti, 63, who lives close to the fence’s path, says he lost 88 olive trees last month and now fears for a nearby family burial plot. The village’s lawyer, Ghiath Nasser, says he won a temporary order to stop work on that section until the High Court of Justice decides what should be done with the graves of Barghouti’s parents and grandmother.

The house of a neighbor, Omar Hajajla, lies just outside Walajeh’s barrier loop.

Hajajla said Israeli officials last week informed him his home would be surrounded by its own electric fence.

“This is like putting my entire family in jail,” the father of three young boys said. “My children need to cross four gates to go school. We don’t know how it will work out, but I’m sure it will be hell for my entire family.”

Some will argue that if the Palestinians had chosen peace the barrier and the many issues emanating from its construction would have been unnecessary.

It’s stories such as this which undermine Israel’s international standing and fuel the ‘apartheid’ slur and provide oxygen to those who want to destroy chances of peace.

These are difficult issues,  and although I understand the reasons for the barrier, the emiseration of the lives of these particular villagers is not something Israel or its suppporters, myself included, can be proud of.

Maybe someone could enlighten me and persuade me that this is necessary and there is no alternative.

Hamas hospital hypocrisy

Interesting article on Arutz Sheva website a few days ago.

Israeli medicine is second to none. We saw their magnificent response to the Haiti earthquake.

In her article Maayana Miskin tells us that in the Ichilov hospital in Tel Aviv in the heart of the Zionist entity, 100 patients a month from Gaza are treated.

Yes, you read that correctly, 100 per month. One hospital.

But that’s not all. It also treats foreign Arabs from countries that don’t even recognise Israel.

But that’s not all. The relatives of these Arabs are provided with free food (presumably Halal) and a place to stay.

But that’s not all. It’s just one of several hospitals that do this.

And as a Druze Knesset minister, Ayoub Kara,  points out, Hamas gives nothing in return for this. Well he’s wrong about that. They send hundreds of missile towards amongst other things, hospitals in Sderot and Ashkelon.

And Gilad Shalit still remains a prisoner for four years with no Red cross/Crescent visits.

This is Israel’s version of Humanitarian Aid. It doesn’t arrive with metal bars and knives, just the odd scalpel.

What sort of mentality is this that so demonises the Jews yet accepts their medical care?

Yes, Israel is not perfect, but who else treats its enemies like this in the Middle East?

Arab Palestinian Zionist – now you didn’t expect that

I was tipped off today about a new web site www.palestinianzionistorganisation.com. I thought it had to be a hoax, but no, it’s for real.

This website, was founded by Elias Issa, a Palestinian Arab whose support of Israel is far greater than a lot of Israelis, so it seems.

His politics are way to the right. But what he says and what he believes is more powerful because it comes from him rather than Jewish Zionists.

However, beware, he doesn’t believe in the creation of a Palestinian state and he wants to build the Third Temple! Like now! (which is actually against Jewish Law and Israeli law)

Here’s what his About Us page says:

[He confirms] the statement of the World Zionist Organization which was defined by the First Zionist Congress in Basel, the Palestinian Zionist Organization agrees, confirms and declares that “The aim of Zionism is to create for the Jewish people a home in Eretz Israel secured by public law”. The PZO is an organization which supports the Nation of Israel and the Jewish people.

A lot of the material on the site could easily have been written by mainstream Israel supporters.

If his views were not so extreme, this might me an important site and an important voice. The problem is that he can be dismissed as a crank, a self-hating Arab Palestinian.

However, any voice that comes from outside the Jewish world and in particular from the Palestinian world that seeks to expose the lies and deceit of his own people deserves to be listened to, even though it is a bit over the top. Were he an Israeli, he’d be in the ultra-Orthodox or the far right camp.

But he’s not a Jew and he’s not an Israeli. He’s a Palestinian who lives in the USA.